guardian at paulcarvill.com, the home of Paul Carvill on the web

link: paulcarvill on twitter

link: paulcarvill at flickr

paulcarvill.com

Hi, I'm Paul Carvill, I'm a web developer. I'm currently working as Technical Lead at LBi, Europe's largest digital agency.

I also like walking, cooking, Bollywood and rock 'n' roll.

Archive for the ‘guardian’ Category

Infovore says: “The most compelling case should be for game-ness”

Wednesday, February 24th, 2010

This is a great post by Infovore on the Guardian’s — amongst others’ — misguided attempt to ‘elevate’ Bioshock 2 to the level of literature. You really have to read the Guardian review of the game, but what struck me is that it wasn’t even being compared to great literature, a cultural item whose quality stands out from the rest. It was being likened to any literature, ie. another cultural form entirely, one that the Guardian, and most other media orgs, consider superior.

Image by 96dpi

I’m not a huge gamer, and I tend to go for quick, puzzle-y games rather than the prolonged, frenetic thumb-bashing which most shooters seem to entail. I can’t stand the pace. But I was certainly bewitched by the descriptions of Bioshock 2 as a new type of narrative experience, almost a new cultural event. Hmmm, I thought, maybe this erudite, psychologically sound, mature piece of sensory immersion was for me. Perhaps it will reveal depths in me, and itself, that no one knew existed. So I pissed myself laughing when I read Infovore’s paragraph:

“Bioshock 2 is a shooter – a very good shooter, sure, with some tactical elements harking back to Halo’s balance of left-hand/right-hand, direct/indirect – but it’s still a game where you spend most of your time shooting monsters in the face.”

Probably not for me after all, then. But I think I actually would have been really angry had I shelled out 40 quid for a fairly traditional game which poncey critics were trying to legitimise up the wazoo by conferring their favourite elements of other entertainment formats onto.

More coverage of the Guardian’s Open Platform API

Thursday, March 12th, 2009

Some more links to coverage of the Guardian’s Open Platform API announcement (some of these found via blogs.journalism.co.uk, thanks):

What people are saying about the Guardian’s Open Platform

Wednesday, March 11th, 2009

I’ve collected together some of the recent articles and blogposts about yesterday’s announcement of the Guardian’s Open Platform strategy and, below, some of the first apps that people have built:

And here are some of the first apps that people have built using the Open Platform API:

Guardian Open Platform

Wednesday, March 11th, 2009

There was exciting news yesterday morning, when we announced the next stage of the Guardian’s stated strategy to be the world’s leading liberal voice. The Guardian is opening out — making our content available for other people to use — and also opening in — allowing developers to build on our platform and deploy applications which extend its functionality.

So, the headlines from the announcement are:

  • Open Platform API
    • search, query, filter and discover content, keywords and tags from the Guardian’s archive
    • contains full textual content of all Guardian articles going back to 1999
    • currently in private beta (apply for a key)
    • free for the first 5000 queries per day
    • can be used for commercial purposes (you can make money by running ads with it)
    • it will at some point in the future be ad-supported on pages using the full content
  • Data Store
    • a curated collection of data sets
    • researched, verified and attributed to its source
    • hosted on Google Docs and free to use
    • covering subjects such as diverse as US economic data, environmental statistics, crime figures and religious information
  • Data Blog
    • accompanies the Data Store
    • will provide information around the raw data: how we sourced it, why we use that particular data set, what the information might mean

This constitutes a wealth of information to announce in one go, and it may take people some time to digest it all. The really exciting thing about this move is that we’re putting the full content of our articles out there for people to use. The implications for data mining, linguistic research and deep textual comparisons are endless, and I’m really looking forward to seeing what people come up with. Having context to the data is really important, so people can do much, much more than just link back to our site using a headline or an excerpt.

The Data Store is also a really bold move. Simon Rogers, one of our News Editors, and the journalists here put amazing amounts of effort into research, and here we are returning the fruit of their labour into the community. Of course, we use that research to report and editorialise, but here we give you the opportunity to derive your own patterns and meaning from the same data. The fact that this stuff has been manually sourced, collated and published makes it mean so much more, and I’m sure people, including other journalists, will find it an increasingly useful source of information for years to come.

I’ve collected some useful links here which are specifically related to the Open Platform:

I’ve also collected some of the news coverage and blogposts about the announcement here:

Guardian TechTalk with OpenStreetMap — Steve Coast

Sunday, February 15th, 2009

These are some notes from memory:

We had Steve Coast from OpenStreetMap at a Guardian TechTalk on Friday 13th February 2009. Steve Coast now lives in San Francisco, and works with a couple of developers there, plus a couple more in Russia. He talked about the OpenStreetMap Foundation, of which he is the Chairman. OpenStreetMap has no employees, Steve Coast spends most of his time getting one volunteer to interact with another.

OpenStreetMap giving a Guardian TechTalk

Google Maps, Windows Live maps and other big online maps use costly data bought from big mapping companies like NAVTEQ and Tele Atlas, who in turn also purchse mapping info from people like Ordnance Survey. You mostly cannot reuse or derive products from this data. They map using big trucks driving around collecting GPS data, and that data is updated every 18 months – almost exactly the lifespan of your average TomTom, so the purchase of a new one goes directly to fund a new round of mapping. They can’t map where the trucks can’t go. And they’re not interested in OpenStreetMaps free data.

OpenStreetMap operates on a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike license – you are free to use the data, edit and update it, as long as you attribute OpenStreetMap as the original source of the data and also share your edits back into the community.

Dealing with conflict – in more than one sense of the word. Maps, as everyone knows, are power. Areas of conflict have a tendency for people to redraw the borders. Steve Coast plainly has better things to do, and other things to worry about – he basically doesn’t care how people use the service, and only once so far have they had to ban users.

On the subject of China – Steve is fairly resigned. He sees any action on his part to persuade China to allows its citizens to freely access OpenStreetMap as futile. Google bent over backwards to get access to China,

‘and they’re not evil, right?’

he says,

’so what difference can I make’.

His philosophy boils down to ‘I made a thing which makes a map. so either use it to make a map, or don’t. I don’t make money out of it, so what do I care?

Aerial magery used includes some provided under federal law by the US Government. Yahoo also kindly allow their aerial imagery to be used. Most people start by tracing this into a map. The Netherlands’ biggest mapping company donated all their Netherlands map data — when they looked at it to check all was working shortly after they donated it, it had been updated and edited so heavily they no longer recognised it!

Mapping parties organise groups of people with small GPS devices to map an area. Handheld device is about the same size as a chunky mobile phone. OpenStreetMap loans the deices out so people can contribute mapping data, or you can use your own devices. Data is then uploaded by computer and converted into bitmapped map tiles.

All mapping data by each user is recorded. In the event of someone copying data illegally by tracing copyrighted maps, OpenStreetMap’s policy is to ‘fail quickly and remove all the offending person’s data.’

Mpping data is incremented every night. The map data file is currently about 5Gb.

Everything is hosted at University College, London, where the project was started. Asked how they felt about hosting it, or if they even knew it was there, Steve Coast said,

‘the right people know it’s there’.

You can map anything – pubs, postboxes, roads, footpaths. He shows an example where the OpenStreetMap data is more current and more accurate than Google’s – university campuses, for example – buildings, footpaths are all mapped, where Google shows just a grey area.

Is currently involved in looking for sponsorship, is willing to talk to anyone. Had their first fundraising drive in 2008 for new hardware, made $17,000 in 2 days.

Steve talked to Ordnance Survey, advised us, ‘don’t invest in them if they ever go public’.

Good graphical presentation on updates around the globe over a year-long period. Uptake follows the pattern of a large increase following mapping party, dropping by about 10% soon afterwards and from there continuing at that flat level. They haven’t generally see nmuch drop off after that anywhere.

When asked several tricky questions, Steve Coast repeats the mantra, ‘you fix it.’ The software is open source – if you want something done, do it, or find someone who can do it for you.

Finally, he mentions FreeThePostcode, a campaign to get a free, public database of UK postcodes to rival the Royal Mail’s paid-for model. There is an iPhone app – the idea is that you upload an accurate GPS point and the correct postcode for that point, which is then added to the database and will eventually be made available freely.

Lots of this information, and more, is available at the OpenStreetMap wiki.